The First Five Minutes: Traps and Snap Judgments
You walk into classroom 531 on the fifth floor, on a missive to deliver your best first lecture of the fall semester. You smile and say hello to your new students, expecting a wave of friendly faces in return. A few look up from their laptops and grin back, and you instantly decide these will be the “easy” students who like you best. You like them best, too. You take your place at the podium when a student texting on their phone catches your eye. A sudden thought flits across your mind: this student may be trouble. Just like that, assumptions are formed before class even begins. First impressions can stick.
From an evolutionary standpoint, this urge to make snap judgments makes you more than just judgy. It is an adaptive survival mechanism rather than a superficial flaw (Zebrowitz, 2017). Our human ancestors had to rapidly assess the lay of the land to detect threats, so gut reactions kept them safe. But in a modern college classroom free from creatures and carnivores, that ancient instinct can lead to a severe misassessment of the terrain. When a student meets your greeting with silence or a blank stare, their quiet response most likely has nothing to do with you.
Deciphering the Blank Stare
A flat expression is not an automatic sign of hostility, an indictment of your teaching, or a sign of personal animosity. In reality, a reserved student is usually dealing with one of a dozen unspoken realities. The quiet one in the back might be a first-generation student who has never stepped foot inside a college classroom. Another might be experiencing imposter syndrome, afraid to stand out. Some students simply land lower on the extroversion or openness scales, while others may be dealing with physical or mental health challenges that make emotional expressions more difficult to muster. It could simply be that they are daydreaming, having a difficult day, or lost in a laptop screen.
While managing screens is a real challenge—one that can be addressed by keeping a room mostly tech-free and offering old-school notebooks and pens as incentives as I do—the main takeaway is simple. An inexpressive or stoic student is not an adversary. But it makes sense why your brain may register them as one. When someone gives you a still face, you instinctively flag the expression as a threat to the relationship. Because humans are meaning-makers, we interpret a blank face as rejection. Inattention and disengagement may be just as damaging as actual conflict because it leaves you stuck in an uncertain state, wondering if you matter to the other person (Tronick, 1989).
The Neural Overlap of Rejection
This connection between social rejection and physical pain is deeply biological. Research from a meta-analysis of over 500 published studies shows that when rejection is powerfully elicited, like having someone who recently experienced an unwanted breakup view a photograph of their ex-partner, the specific brain regions that support the sensory components of physical pain, such as the secondary somatosensory cortex and the dorsal posterior insula, become highly active (Kross et al., 2011).
This means that social heartbreak and physical injury share the same neural real estate. When brain scans look at someone experiencing severe rejection, the areas lighting up are the same ones that register an actual physical injury, like a broken bone or a burn. Your brain does not distinguish between a wounded body and a wounded ego. These results give literal meaning to the idea that rejection hurts! It is no surprise that our language equates social pain and estrangement with words typically reserved for physical injury, like being crushed, shattered, or having a broken heart (Eisenberger & Lieberman, 2004).
From Cooing to Crying: The Psychology of the Blank Face
It is human nature to like people who like us. We tend to withdraw from those who shun us with a still face. This phenomenon traces back to Edward Tronick’s famous psychology experiment, which demonstrated how a mother’s neutral, still face left a baby feeling sequestered and scared.
To visualize this, picture a mother and her baby interacting, facing each other, smiling, and playing. Everything feels warm and connected. Suddenly, the mother goes completely blank. No smile, no reaction, just a neutral, stony expression, like her face just went on pause. At first, the baby tries to get her attention by smiling, cooing, and waving their little arms. When that fails, confusion turns to frustration. Some babies cry or scream before eventually collapsing into a state of helpless withdrawal. From their perspective, the safe emotional connection is gone, and they cannot get it back (Tronick et al., 1978).
The Trap of the Negative Narrative
Babies are hardwired to demand social reciprocity, but professors enjoy no such evolutionary leverage. While it’s hard not to react negatively to a face that seems unwelcoming,
We cannot throw a tantrum, scream, or shake our fists in the air to force a student to pay attention, smile back at us, or put their phone away. Likewise, publicly singling out a seemingly disengaged student with a sarcastic or critical remark is never effective. This can easily fracture the classroom climate and make everyone feel uncomfortable. A successful classroom fosters group cohesion, creating the emotional bond and sense of belonging that transforms a room of individuals into a supportive learning community (Yalom & Leszcz, 2020). Without that foundational safety, trust can evaporate and tension can spread.
I teach in the psychology department, so I’d like to think that my background has helped me foster a more patient, caring perspective toward students. When I walk into a classroom and cheerfully ask, “How was your break?” and am met with indifference by a few students, I am aware of the importance of avoiding snap judgements or viewing the class as an amorphous whole. Teachers who assume a class is distant or chilly will naturally start to pull back to protect their own warmth.
Attachment Styles in the Classroom
Instead of worrying about rejection, instructors can zoom out and recognize that “still faces” may reflect a student’s childhood attachment style. Avoidant and anxious individuals tend to maintain the same behavioral patterns in school as they do in their interpersonal relationships, using attachment as an innate emotion regulation system to modulate stress (Fraley & Roisman, 2019).
When we view the classroom through this lens, we can cautiously seek out the students who may never otherwise visit our office hours. According to research by Gore and Rogers (2010), a student’s childhood attachment style significantly influences how they handle academic goals. Their study found that securely attached students tend to thrive and earn higher grades when their academic motivations are tied to the interests of important people in their lives. In other words, when a secure student knows their parents are proud of them, or when they have a professor who checks in on them, it acts like fuel. They think, “People care about me and want me to succeed,” and that makes them study harder and get better grades.
In contrast, avoidant students may eschew the involvement of others. Even when a professor reaches out with genuine support, offers help, or tries to learn about their goals, an avoidant student may panic. To them, your involvement feels like pressure, control, or a trap (Gore & Rogers, 2010). From the theoretical perspective of Rentzios and Karagiannopoulou (2021), this behavior is an intentional, self-protective strategy used to regulate overwhelming emotions during the learning process. Because avoidant students may view closeness with an authority figure (the professor) as dangerous or unstable, they might keep that bonding instinct firmly turned off, projecting a lack of interest.
In this way, a student’s blank gaze, apparent boredom, or surface-level effort is actually a sophisticated psychological defense mechanism (Rentzios & Karagiannopoulou, 2021). It is a behavioral pattern meant to avoid emotional risk by keeping both the course material and the professor at a safe, non-threatening distance.
Making Space in Room 531
In my classroom, I’m not trying to force an introverted or anxious student to become a bubbly extrovert. I’m just trying to show them that I am a reliable, safe professional. When an avoidant student realizes that their still face doesn’t make me upset, lose energy, or pull back my support, their defense system often slowly begins to deactivate.
I believe the worst thing a teacher can do is give up on a quiet, reserved class by delivering a cold or distant lecture. Instead, we must show up with the same level of enthusiasm, structure, warmth, and clarity every single week. Ultimately, a blank face is not a personal insult or a threat to our authority. Once we drop defensiveness or snap judgments, we create space for genuine connection, setting the stage for a positive classroom culture that supports learning and growth.
Beverly Wertheimer, PsyD, DMin, LCSW, teaches in the graduate school of psychology at Pepperdine University and is winner of the 2026 national Adjunct Faculty Excellence in Teaching Award from the Society for the Teaching of Psychology, a division of the American Psychological Association. Dr. Wertheimer is a child and adolescent psychotherapist, certified life coach, and author specializing in pedagogy and mental health. She has a background in broadcast journalism, including correspondent stints at ABC and NBC affiliates, as well as CNN’s entertainment news programs.
References
Eisenberger, N. I., & Lieberman, M. D. (2004). Why rejection hurts: A common neural alarm system for physical and social pain. Trends in Cognitive Sciences, 8(4), 189–200. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.tics.2004.05.010
Fraley, R. C., & Roisman, G. I. (2019). The development of adult attachment: A long-term longitudinal study of NICHD study of early childcare and youth development. Psychological Science, 30(6), 825–838.
Gore, J. S., & Rogers, M. J. (2010). Why Do I Study? The Moderating Effect of Attachment Style on Academic Motivation. The Journal of Social Psychology, 150, 560-578.
E. Kross, M.G. Berman, W. Mischel, E.E. Smith, & T.D. Wager. (2011). Social rejection shares somatosensory representations with physical pain. National Academy of Sciences. 108 (15) 6270-6275, https://doi.org/10.1073/pnas.1102693108
Rentzios, C. and Karagiannopoulou, E. (2021) Rethinking Associations between Distal Factors and Learning: Attachment, Approaches to Learning and the Mediating Role of Academic Emotions. Psychology, 12, 899-924. https://doi.org/10.4236/psych.2021.126055
Tronick, E. Z. (1989). Emotions and emotional communication in infants. American Psychologist, 44(2), 112–119. https://doi.org/10.1037/0003-066X.44.2.112
Tronick, E., Als, H., Adamson, L., Wise, S., & Brazelton, T. B. (1978). The infant’s response to entrapment between contradictory messages in face-to-face interaction. Journal of the American Academy of Child Psychiatry, 17(1), 1–13. https://doi.org/10.1016/S0002-7138(09)62273-1
Yalom, I. D., & Leszcz, M. (2020). The theory and practice of group psychotherapy (6th ed.). Basic Books.
Zebrowitz, L. A. (2017). First impressions from faces. Current Directions in Psychological Science, 26(3), 237–242. https://doi.org/10.1177/0963721416683996