February 15th, 2017

Timeless Quotes for Teaching and Learning Inspiration

By:

highlighting text in journal article

Teaching Professor Blog One of my New Year’s resolutions was to reread some of my favorite teaching and learning resources, especially those I haven’t looked at in a while. I’m enjoying these revisits and decided to share some random quotes with timeless insights.


“All discussion of reform must begin with the ordinary student, not the genius, not the prospective scientist or professor of abnormal psychology but the citizen of the republic who must earn a living in addition to living a humane life.”
– Paige Smith, Killing the Spirit: Higher Education in America, 1990, p. 200


“Good students are those who learn. Whatever their preconceptions, barriers or deficits—whatever their story—they take new information and new experiences, and to the best of their ability, make them tools for transforming themselves and their world. And at last I’ve learned that a good teacher is someone who can recognize and connect with good students—in all their forms.”
– Mark Cohan, “Bad Apple: The Social Production and Subsequent Reeducation of a Bad Teacher,” Change, November/December, 2009, p. 36


“Our students live in cacophony. Clamour, chatter and din fill their ears, and may even injure them. To many, a moment of silence in unendurable. I cannot ask them to put their heads down on their desk and be quiet, as Mrs. Morgan commanded me to do in Grade 2. But we can educate ourselves to be models of intellectuals who trust and value silence, who practice what we have always known; when no one is speaking, someone is learning. We can create oases of silence where cool springs of insight trickle and flow.”
– Ron Marken, in Silences, 2008, p. 115


“Most teachers resist showing students the dirty part of real learning and by the dirty part I don’t mean the hard work…. I mean the part where we fail nine times in a row before we find a good approach. I mean the parts where we are confused about our project, defensive in the face of criticism, doubtful of our abilities…. Whatever the venue … teachers like modeling their knowledge, not their ignorance, and they avoid referring to the muddy paths, fear-filled moments, and just plain failure that are the unavoidable parts of getting the knowledge we possess.”
– Marshall Gregory, “From Shakespeare on the Page to Shakespeare on the Stage,” Pedagogy, 2006, p. 324


“Skills as complex as questioning, listening and response are learned step-by-step; mastery is a climb up a ladder, not a pole vault.”
– C. Roland Christensen, Education for Judgment: The Artistry of Discussion Leadership, 1991, p. 156


“If members of another profession—say surgeons—were like college teachers, they would perform in isolation without apprenticeships, learning to cut and sew by trial and error. They would know anatomy but be ignorant of biology. They would hold colloquia discussing incision tips and suture innovations. To demonstrate the quality of their work, they would ask surviving patients to fill out bubble-sheet questionnaires with items like: ‘Does the surgeon demonstrate a commanding knowledge of his field? Is the surgeon well organized? Did she show respect for patients?’ No one would look at survival rates.”
– Larry D. Spence, “The Case Against Teaching,” Change, November/December, 2001, p. 14


“Research is about as compatible with undergraduate teaching as lions are with lambs. Only by one devouring the other are they likely to lie down comfortably side by side
– Kenneth E. Eble, The Craft of Teaching, 2nd ed., 1988, xiii


“The teaching life is the life of the explorer, the creator, constructing the classroom for free exploration. It is about engagement. It takes courage. It is about ruthlessly excising what is flawed, what no longer fits, no matter how difficult it was to achieve. It is about recognizing teaching as a medium that can do some things exquisitely but cannot do everything.”
– Christa L. Walck, “A Teaching Life,” Journal of Management Education, November, 1997, p. 481


“Learning is my daily bread. It is wholly selfish, I fear, but I feel more alive in a community of learners than anywhere else. I am a voyeur, a peeping tom. I like to watch other people doing it almost as much as doing it myself. But unexpected (yet dependable) flashes of intuition or dogged discoveries or familiar ideas enlighten and warm me and make my joy complete. Every day.”
– Peter G. Beidler in Distinguished Teachers on Effective Teaching, New Directions for Teaching and Learning, No. 28, 1986



  • Angela Daniels

    Great quotes! Thanks.

  • Perry W Shaw

    Thanks so much Maryellen. Your passion for quality education shines through. Of course these quotes raise major questions about the shape of higher education, in particular the assumption that a PhD qualifies you to teach, but that is an issue for another day! 🙂

  • Jason

    Thanks Maryellen, I like the human perspective these touch on. We must strive to make the best educational decisions for all in the group, not just those achieving highly, or conversely those at the low end of the spectrum. I agree, that although it can be difficult being open to students about achieving success through a series of failures, this can really generate an honest and respectful classroom, as well as provide that motivation to persevere.

    I teach a very practical course, where outside practice is a necessity for success, and love giving the students this anonymous quote:
    “Nothing works until you do.”

    Thanks!

  • Gonzalo Munevar

    Many of the quotes are good, but Eble’s claim that research is incompatible with undergraduate teaching is nonsense. During my undergraduate days and in my over 40 years of teaching in all sorts of universities — small, large, research, liberal arts, public, private, etc. — my experience was the opposite. The best researchers tended to be the best teachers. On the other hand, people who did little research tended to be mediocre teachers as well. This is not surprising. When you have a talent and a passion to explore the frontiers of knowledge, you are better able to guide students in their own explorations of knowledge.

  • Luis M

    Varying quality… I am fairly sure that these quotes are from non-STEM writers, so there is parochialism. Ron Marken is on the mark, while Larry Spence creates the lankiest of weak analogies. And Marshall Gregory is generalizing beyond his field. For example, we in mathematics MUST model knowledge, there is no time to model ignorance. If one did, the first to catch the fakery are the good students, and the weak ones would accept the falsehoods whole cloth. Rather, we say, “tough question you raise, let’s look at it with more time.” And we don’t avoid telling of the “muddy paths.” I tell my students that those who work in math/physics require the largest erasers. But sometimes, just sometimes, there is the eureka moment, as Archimedes truly appreciated. But then, I agree with his “just plain failure that are the unavoidable parts of getting the knowledge we possess.”
    Anyway, thank you, Maryellen Weimer.