May 7, 2014

Teaching Encounter Provides an Up-Close Look at Learning Something New

By: in Teaching Professor Blog

Add Comment

I just taught a dear friend how to knit, and in doing so I revisited how very challenging it is to teach something you can do easily.

Knitting, like so many of the skills we teach, including concrete skills like running a lathe and abstract ones like critical thinking, cannot be learned in theory. It is learned by doing. “Now you try,” I say after several slow, deliberate demonstrations of the motions. Oh my, such clumsy confusion. “Here, let me show you again.” I slow down even further and talk through the movements needed to make a stitch. Good gracious, I can hardly watch these tortured, truncated movements, so far from the peaceful, rhythmic flow of knitting. As the confusion continues, thoughts start going through my mind. How many times am I going to have to show her? It can’t possibly be this hard? And why am I feeling frustrated?

I worry about order and pacing. Knitting starts (and ends) with two basic stitches, knit and purl. She has those, sort of. Is it time to move on? What’s next? Common combinations of the two basic stitches? Or should I work on her technique? She’s got to stop propping the needles up on her belly. And we need to move on to something other than this scraggly “sampler” (as she calls it). The needle size and yarn weight are creating something less than lovely. It’s not the kind of knitting that inspires continued effort and she still has lots to learn. I search for something that she can do. It needs to offer challenge but also the strong possibility of success.

Then there are the mistakes. I have forgotten how many ways there are to do it wrong. I aspire to learner-centered teaching, which means she needs to take the lead in identifying and fixing her mistakes. Great in theory—hard in practice, I quickly discover. She fixes things slowly, laboriously, and that takes time away from knitting. She focuses with intense ferocity, which is not only tiring, but it seems to lead to even more errors. And some of the mistakes are serious. Whole rows must come out. I step in and make some of the corrections, wondering if that’s a good idea.

My mind whirls. What feedback do I need to provide? How many corrective messages? I think I’m offering too many and they’re worded so negatively. “No, not over the needle, the yarn goes between the two needles.” “No, that’s not a purl bump.” I should be more positive. I should be asking more questions, offering hints, and making helpful suggestions.

She’s trying so hard. Will she notice if I laud the effort and not the knitting? She is improving but more slowly than I expected. I look at her work and know it would be dishonest to call it good. “Look here, see these four stitches? Wow! They are so smooth. That’s exactly what you want. Good job.” She sighs. I sigh. This is hard work.

We have four days together with books to discuss, walks to take, and a friendship to celebrate. Despite working diligently on the knitting, we are running out of time. I’m afraid she isn’t ready to do this on her own. I buy her books and talk about online resources. She will need the help of a couple friends—people she tells me aren’t good teachers. I feel like I’ve failed.

My flight leaves early. I’m getting the coffee on and there on the counter sits her project—or is it her project? Oh my God, she has done 12 error-free rows! I look more closely. Yup, there are no mistakes. She’s beside me now. Joy dances from her face to mine. “I did it!” “Yes, you did and it looks beautiful!” We hug, celebrating the learning and the teaching.

It’s good to have these in-your-face teaching experiences, I decide. With so many students and too much content to teach, it’s easy to miss the struggles of individual learners and not notice how teacher actions aid or confound the process. It’s easy to be perplexed by a learner’s confusion and quickly draw conclusions about ability. Most important, it’s easy to forget that what now seems simple, straightforward, and perfectly obvious is usually not that way when it’s first encountered. Teaching takes a lot of patience; learning takes a lot of persistence.

email
Add Comment


Comments

Julie Abraham | May 7, 2014

What a beautifully written reminder of how hard both teaching & learning are! It's especially relevant as I read my students' final portfolios in which they demonstrate and reflect on their own learning process throughout the semester. Some have traveled farther along the path of learning than others, but this piece reminds me that every step brings these learners–and me!–closer to our destinations (even if most of us never quite reach the end!). Thank you for sharing! :-)

Abby Selby | May 7, 2014

What a lovely analogy! Insightful and heart warming

lauriesrestingplace | May 7, 2014

Just met with parents of a student with severe dyslexia. Now appreciating those teachers I've met who do see kids individually despite the curtain of content that too often covers them up:
"With so many students and too much content to teach, it’s easy to miss the struggles of individual learners and not notice how teacher actions aid or confound the process. It’s easy to be perplexed by a learner’s confusion and quickly draw conclusions about ability. Most important, it’s easy to forget that what now seems simple, straightforward, and perfectly obvious is usually not that way when it’s first encountered. Teaching takes a lot of patience; learning takes a lot of persistence."

Corinne McNamara | May 7, 2014

I appreciate your description of the teaching/learning process. I've used knitting, painting, and cooking to illustrate the idea that expertise in writing isn't an inborn skill. Patience, persistence, and practice are essential to learning anything new or different. You've said it beautifully!

David | May 7, 2014

I was all prepared for your friend to fail when she snatched victory from the jaws of defeat. What a great story!

NT Lester | May 7, 2014

Three insights I got out of the article, which I'm going to recall as I design ESL instruction: 1) Practice makes progress 2) Effort affects outcome. 3) The pre- and post- instructional "samplers" were observable demonstrations of the student's progress. Thanks very much for posting.

Carolyn Batterson | May 9, 2014

what a great story. been there, done that several times and I AM talking about knitting.
My little girl, Sherry, can attest to that.


Trackbacks

  1. There are no trackbacks to this post yet.


website security